"From the iconic opening to the well-judged restraint of the slow movement and the blazing energy of the finale, the BBC Philharmonic are on magnificent form throughout, bearing comparison with the finest recordings in the catalogue. The Chandos engineers have captured the tension and drama with their customary skill."
Andrew Palmer - Yorkshire Times - April 2026
'This strong, clearly articulated and sonically vivid performance from John Storgårds and the BBC Philharmonic, alongside the highly charged singing of the CBSO Chorus, makes the best possible case for taking the work more seriously.'
Erik Levi - BBC Music Magazine - May 2026
'This is a notable addition to a strong cycle. If I’ve written more about the Symphony No. 2 here, that’s largely down to the enthusiasm of rediscovery — I still can’t get that extraordinary opening out of my head. Storgårds’s Fifth, meanwhile, matches the best of what has come before.'
Dominic Hartley - MusicWeb International - 24 March 2026
'I am also particularly struck by the clarity and precision of the BBC Philharmonic in their execution of the highly complex counterpoint and cross-rhythmic passages and the committed, authentic-sounding contribution of the CBSO Chorus...The contribution of the soloists, too, led by leader Yuri Torchinsky in his torturous violin riffs, is very impressive and Storgårds very skilfully manages the gradual transition from the fragmentary, disorienting idiom of the first three sections into the much more tonal – possibly ironic, given the banality of the text – style of the choral ode.'
Ralph Moore - MusicWeb International - 14 April 2026
'there’s power in the way [Storgårds] warms the sound when the harmonies turn towards the light, and the third movement has a compelling feeling of stillness.'
Erica Jeal - The Guardian - 3 April 2026
'This is a compelling Fifth – first-class playing by BBC Philharmonic (Yuri Torchinsky, leader), immaculate production by Mike George, superbly recorded by Stephen Rinker...No matter how many Fifths you have, I suggest this from Storgårds is a must-have.'
Colin Anderson - colinscolumn.com - 19 March 2026